The Skincare Products I Secretly Judge (But Still Love and Use)

There are two types of skincare products in my life: The ones I recommend without hesitation. And the ones I judge a little… while quietly restocking before I run out. This is about category number two. Because if you’ve ever stared at a $300 cream and thought, “Absolutely not”… only to add to cart 48 hours later—welcome. You are among friends. Consider this a safe space for your most luxurious, slightly unhinged beauty decisions. Let’s get into it.

Click on the images for links*‍

The Overpriced Facial Collection (That I Refuse to Give Up) ‍

Doctor Diamond Metacine InstaFacial® Collection. Let me start by saying: this is not a casual, once-in-a-while day spa skincare routine. This is a three-step, serum-and-cream situation that says, “I’m fully committing to my skin—and expecting results.”

Yes, it’s expensive. Yes, I had questions. Many questions. But the first time I used it, my skin looked like I had just done something… clinical.

The glow? Immediate.
The texture? Suspiciously smooth.
The results? Annoyingly good.

Do I judge the price? Absolutely.
Do I keep it on hand for when my skin needs a full personality reset? Also yes.

Editor’s note: This is what I aspire to reach for on the daily. It’s important to have goals.

The “Quiet Luxury” Face Tint That Just Works ‍

Chantecaille Sheer Glow Face Tint. Chantecaille is the brand that whispers instead of shouts—and somehow still gets your full attention. The Sheer Glow Face Tint doesn’t try to impress you immediately. It just quietly makes your skin look better… and better… and better. It’s that effortless, polished, “I drink water and mind my business” skin in a jar.

Do I wish it were less expensive? Of course.
Do I keep reaching for it when I want my skin to look like itself—but elevated? Every time.

Editor’s note: My secret weapon for events, a night out, or days when I want to glow without looking like I tried.

The Cream & Serum Trio I Side-Eye… But Will Repurchase

U Beauty Resurfacing Compound, The Super Hydrator, and The Sculpt Neck + Décolleté Concentrate. I resisted this line. I really did. Everyone loves it, which automatically makes me suspicious. (Editor brain. Occupational hazard.) And yet… the results are hard to argue with.

The Resurfacing Compound refines, smooths, and brightens—without turning your skin into a reactive mess. The Super Hydrator delivers deep hydration without heaviness (critical in Miami humidity, where everything is a test). And the Sculpt? Let’s just say I’m not worried about my neck anymore.

Do I still side-eye the hype? A little.
Do I plan on repurchasing? Consistently.

Editor’s note: If a product makes me stop experimenting and just use it, that says everything.

Bonus: Enjoy 20% off with my code AMIT20.

The Body Cream with the Unhinged Price Tag

La Prairie Cashmere Body Cream. There is expensive… and then there is La Prairie expensive. This cream lives in a category I like to call: “I shouldn’t… but I already did.” It’s indulgent to the point of absurdity—and yet, here we are.

The texture is what gets you. It’s plush, cocooning, and makes your skin feel like it suddenly has better boundaries and a trust fund. The finish is soft, luminous, and quietly expensive-looking.

Do I think body cream should cost this much? No.
Do I use it sparingly like it’s a rare artifact? Yes.
Do I love it? Unfortunately, also yes.

Editor’s note: Not an everyday product. This is a “lock the door, light the candle, and moisturize like you mean it” situation.

The High-Tech Tool I Was Ready to Roll My Eyes At ‍

Current Body LED Red Light Therapy Face Mask. LED masks fall into a very specific category for me: “Do I believe this… or do I just want to?” I was fully skeptical. But after consistent use, I started noticing changes that are hard to fake—smoother texture, a bit more bounce, that subtle “well-rested” look (even when life says otherwise).

Is it a commitment? Yes.
Do you have to actually use it? Also yes.
Is it now part of my routine? Every. Single. Day.

Editor’s note: This is the long game. Not instant gratification—but worth it if you stick with it.

Final Thoughts: A Judgment-Free (But Slightly Judgy) Zone

The truth is, not every product I love makes sense on paper. Some are overpriced. Some are overhyped. Some I fully intended to dislike. And yet—they work. So this is your official permission slip to love the products you side-eye. To keep the cream that makes no financial sense. To repurchase the serum you pretend you’re “still evaluating.” Because at the end of the day? If your skin looks incredible… we’re calling it justified.

Even if we judge it just a little.

*This website may contain affiliate links, meaning I get a commission if you decide to make a purchase through my links, at no cost to you. ‍ ‍